Sciatica? Surgery No Better Than Waiting

Surprised?  Many people are shocked to learn that treating sciatica with surgery is about as effective as doing nothing.

And the basis for making such a claim comes from an important source: the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).

JAMA  published a study in their November 22/29, 2006 issue.  The same study was also reported on in an Association Press (AP) story of November 22, 2006.  The basis for the report comes from two large US government funded studies on patients suffering from sciatica.

Sciatica Study

In this study 472 patients with an average age of 42 were assigned to either have surgery or watchful waiting. However, many of the patients assigned to one of the two groups switched groups and decided to go against the group they were assigned to.

However these subjects were still followed for 2 years to see how they responded from whichever group they ultimately wound up in. Those that had the surgery were compared to those that did not for both bodily pain and physical function.

The study shows that patients who have been diagnosed with herniated disks creating sciatica had “no clear-cut reason to choose an operation over other treatment.”

According to the researchers in this study patients who suffered from these problems showed significant improvement over two years time regardless of whether they had back surgery or not.

Dr. James Weinstein of Dartmouth Medical School and lead author of the study suggested that based on the findings of this study patients should choose whether they want to get the surgery or not, based on their own desires.  He stated…

“If you don’t want the risk of surgery, you can do watchful waiting.”

The article notes that about 250,000 Americans go under the knife for herniated disks each year.

However, they also report that an equal number choose not to have surgery, which costs $6000 on average, and instead choose other types of care.

Care to comment?  We look forward to your feedback on this and related other issues.

Want to find a chiropractor near you?  Simply follow the link to our chiropractic directory.